Vivian Liu

If you’re in the market for a new roof, there are plenty of options at your disposal. But how do you choose? Each has its own strengths and weaknesses as well as situations they are best fit for.

So, before you go ahead and pick a roofing material, however, it’s important to consider the various choices available as well as educate yourself on the pros and cons of each. The ideal material depends on a number of factors, including your budget, durability requirements, aesthetic preferences, and much more.

Below, we’ll dive deep into four popular roofing styles so you can make an informed decision for your unique situation.

Roofing Materials: At a Glance

Here’s an overview of four popular roofing options you may want to explore:

Cedar Shake

A cedar shake roof is composed of natural cedar, which comes from Cedar trees. If you’re looking for a beautiful, natural, and environmentally friendly roof that offers excellent insulation, this option should be on your radar. As long as you care for it properly, a cedar shake roof can last for up to 30 years. The downside of a cedar shake roof is the maintenance it requires. Since it’s susceptible to moss and algae buildup as well as moisture damage, you’ll need to inspect and clean it on a regular basis.

Flat

Contrary to their name, flat roof systems aren’t completely flat. Instead, they feature a small pitch that allows water to drain. These types of roofs are typically seen in places with low rainfall. If you opt for a flat-style roof, you can choose from the following:

• TPO: Thermoplastic Polyolefin (TPO) roofing is a popular flat roofing option recognized for its durability and sustainability. Made from a blend of rubber and plastic, TPO is highly resistant to tears, punctures, and UV damage. Its reflective surface helps lower cooling costs by deflecting heat and sunlight, while its recyclability at the end of its lifespan reduces environmental impact.
• PVC: PVC roofing is a durable single-ply membrane crafted from synthetic plastic polymer reinforced with fiberglass or polyester for added strength. Known for its resilience, PVC can withstand UV radiation, chemical exposure, fuels, and high temperatures without deteriorating. Its reflective surface minimizes heat absorption and helps reduce cooling costs by effectively deflecting sunlight and UV rays.
• Torch down: Torch down roofing, or modified bitumen roofing, is a sturdy and dependable choice for flat roofs. It features sheets of modified bitumen that are heat-welded with a torch to create a seamless, waterproof barrier. This roofing system is valued for its exceptional durability, flexibility, resistance to weathering and UV rays, and, most notably, its cost-effectiveness.

Metal

In recent years, metal roofs have become very popular due to their impressive durability, energy efficiency, and long lifespans. Whether you opt for aluminum, steel, or copper, a metal roof has the potential to last 50 years or more with proper maintenance. If energy efficiency is your top priority, a metal roof is worth exploring. The main downside of metal roofs, however, is their higher upfront costs. They’re also noisier than other types of roofs, especially during hail or rain storms.

Asphalt Shingle

When most people think of roofs, asphalt shingle roofs are usually the first option that comes to mind. Due to their easy installation and affordable price point, asphalt shingles are considered the most common roofing style. If you go this route, you can opt for three-tab shingles, which are separated into three sections and offer a minimalistic look.

Another option is architectural shingles, which are designed to replicate other types of roofs and provide greater dimension. Both types of asphalt shingles are long-lasting and can remain in good shape for up to 30 years. In addition, they come in countless colors and styles, so you’re bound to find an asphalt shingle that aligns with your home’s aesthetics and personal preferences.

How to Choose the Right Roofing Material

As you explore various roofing options, here are several factors to keep in mind:

• Your Budget: Think about what you want to spend on a roof. If you’re cost-conscious, asphalt shingles are likely your best bet. However, if you want to splurge on a long-lasting roof, you may benefit from a metal roof. But also keep in mind that investing in a more durable roofing system will likely save you money in the long run as it will last longer, and you won’t have to pay for as many repairs.
• Your Maintenance Preferences: Some roofs require more maintenance than others. If you don’t want to worry about regular maintenance, you should go with an extremely low-maintenance option like metal. Other options like asphalt shingles and cedar shake require consistent inspections and maintenance to ensure they remain in good condition.
• Your Aesthetic Preferences: Different roofing materials offer various visual styles, as mentioned in our table above. Some are modern, some are timeless/classic, and some are extremely versatile and can be used for different vibes. So, you’ll need to consider what aesthetic fits your personal style as well as your home’s architectural integrity.
• Your Durability Needs: If durability is a top priority, consider materials that have a stronger resistance to weather, UV rays, and wear, such as metal or slate. Asphalt shingles are not as long-lasting under harsh conditions compared to those materials.
• Your Location: Climate plays a significant role in choosing the right roofing material. In regions with heavy snowfall or frequent rainfall, a durable option like metal may be the best choice due to its water-shedding properties. If you are in a warmer climate, a more lightweight, reflective option might be a better fit.

If it’s time to replace the roof on your home or commercial building, you may want to consider a metal roof. Since your roof is an important investment, be sure to consider the benefits and drawbacks of this option before taking the plunge. Your budget, lifestyle, preferences, and location will all determine whether metal roofing is worthwhile. To help you decide, we’ve compiled this handy list of pros and cons.

Benefits of Metal Roofing

In recent years, metal roofs have become more popular than ever before. Here are several reasons this roofing option is so appealing to homeowners and property owners in the Seattle area:

Durability

Regardless of where you live, durability should be top of mind. If you’re in Seattle, a strong roof that can withstand harsh weather events, like winds, storms, hail, and even fire. Fortunately, metal roofs are known for their impressive durability. Believe it or not, a metal roof can last 50 years or more as long as it’s maintained properly. Compared to traditional asphalt shingles, with a typical lifespan of up to 20 years, metal roofs are far more durable.

Rust and Corrosion-resistant

Most modern metal roofs are treated with special coatings to prevent rust and corrosion. This makes them an attractive choice for homeowners or property owners looking for a low-maintenance option that is going to keep its aesthetic appeal year after year.

Low Maintenance

Compared to other types of roofing, metal roofs require minimal upkeep. They are less prone to issues like cracking, warping, loose shingles, or moss growth due to their design and exceptional durability. Occasional inspections to check for dents, scratches, or loose fittings are about all the maintenance they need.

Fire Resistance

Metal roofs are non-combustible, making them an excellent choice for fire-prone areas. Paired with proper underlayment materials, a metal roof can offer additional protection and give homeowners peace of mind that they are protected in the event of a fire.

Energy Efficient

Since metal roofs reflect heat rather than absorb it, they offer exceptional energy efficiency, reducing your costs by up to 25%. During the hot Seattle summers, a metal roof can keep your family and guests comfortable without requiring you to turn up the air conditioning. You may even choose a metal roof with reflective pigments, which may further enhance the efficiency of your home. In the winter, the metal can help insulate your home and in turn, reduce your heating needs.

Versatile

Metal roofs are not created equal. If you shop around, you’ll find countless options with different styles, materials, coatings, and colors. You can also find a metal roof that’s been built to replicate other types of roofs, such as cedar shake, slate, and asphalt roofs. It should be fairly easy to find a metal roofing system that matches your home’s unique architectural style and your particular preferences. You can choose a metal roof that blends in or stands out among other homes in your neighborhood.

Safety

Contrary to popular belief, metal roofs are safe. Even though they’re made of metal, you don’t have to worry about lighting strikes against them. If there’s lightning outside, there’s a low chance it will hit your roof. This is because lightning will usually make its way to the ground area of your home instead of your roof.

Environmentally Friendly

If you’re a homeowner or property owner who prioritizes sustainability, metal roofs are a great choice. Many are made with recycled materials and are themselves recyclable at the end of their life. Additionally, their energy-saving properties reduce overall carbon footprints.

Drawbacks of Metal Roofing

While metal roofing systems offer many advantages, they’re not perfect. Some of the most noteworthy drawbacks of metal roofs include:

Cost

Metal roofs are not a viable option if you’re budget-conscious. Even though they’re incredibly energy efficient and can last for 50 years or longer, they’re significantly more expensive than other roofing materials, such as asphalt shingles, for example. While pricing varies by manufacturer and the specifics of a metal roof, you can expect to pay up to ten times more for a metal roof than asphalt shingles. It’s up to you to do the math and determine if the benefits of a metal roof are worth the higher upfront cost.

Dent Risk

There’s no denying that metal roofs are durable. However, they’re also prone to denting. While they do have the ability to withstand a variety of harsh weather conditions, the risk of dents from high-impact events is still there. A tree branch during a hailstorm may dent your metal roof, so it’s important to be aware of this risk.

Noise

During hail or rainstorms, a metal roof may be loud. The good news is advanced installation techniques and a quality product with solid insulation capabilities can mitigate the noise. Despite the fact that metal roofs can cause more noise than other roofing materials, many homeowners still believe they’re a good idea.

Specialized Installation

Installing a metal roof requires specific expertise. Hiring experienced professionals is essential for ensuring a proper fit and long-term performance. This can add to the overall cost and complexity of your roofing project.

Should I Invest in a Metal Roof?

Whether a metal roof is worthwhile depends on your priorities. If you’re in the market for a durable, eco-friendly roof that stands the test of time, a metal roof can be a smart move. This is particularly true if you don’t mind the higher price tag. However, if you’re on a budget and prefer a more traditional style roof, you might be better off with an asphalt or cedar shake roofing system.

Types of Metal Roofs

If you decide to jump on the metal roof bandwagon, here are the options you can choose from:

• Steel: Steel is a popular choice due to its strength, durability, and lower cost.
• Aluminum: Aluminum roofs are lightweight and resistant to rust, making them a great pick if you live somewhere that’s prone to salt corrosion.
• Copper: With a copper roof, which is usually pricier than other roof options, you can give your home a distinct look.
• Zinc: Zinc roofs are ideal if you’d like a roofing system that can naturally self-heal minor scratches over time.

Your roof is an important part of your home. It safeguards your property from the elements, keeping your belongings safe, your interior dry, and your loved ones protected. In addition, it plays a critical role in the overall structural integrity, durability, and longevity of your home.

While high-quality roofs are typically durable and last for years, especially if they’re properly maintained and professionally installed, they don’t last forever. At some point in time, you may need a new roof. It is news no homeowner likes receiving, but investing in a new roof can actually bring about many benefits and prevent you from having to deal with annoying repairs or pesky issues that often come with an aging roof.

We recommend reaching out to a seasoned roofing company like K Single Corp to examine the roof and inform you of whether a replacement makes sense but you can also look for these eight telltale signs. Some warning signs that indicate you might need a new roof include:

1. Your Roof is Old

The type of roof you have will dictate its lifespan. For example, while an asphalt roof usually lasts between 20 and 30 years, a metal roof can last for 50 or more years. If you believe your roof is on the older side, there’s a good chance it needs to be replaced. An outdated roof won’t be able to protect your home effectively, so while it may be tempting to keep it, doing so can compromise your family’s safety.

2. Your Shingles are Damaged

Just because you have a newer roof doesn’t mean there is no damage. Even if your roof is only 5, 10, or 15 years old, check for damage. If you notice missing, curling, or buckling shingles, it may be past its prime and warrant a replacement. Be sure to focus on the valleys between slopes and seams where the material collides with roof vents, chimneys, or exterior walls. Damage in any of these areas may be a sign of worrisome leaks and water damage.

3. Your Shingles Have Cracks

While cracks on your shingles that stem from rainstorms and strong winds may seem minor, they’re actually a serious problem. They can compromise the integrity of your roof and prevent it from doing its job properly. If you find a few cracked shingles, you may be able to get away with a repair. However, too many of them are likely a sign that you need a new roof.

4. Your Home Has Water Damage

Water damage to your roof as well as the walls and ceilings in your home, is a sign that your roof may need to be replaced. Some of the most common signs of water damage include water stains, more humidity, higher heating and cooling costs that you can’t explain, clogged gutters, and uncomfortable roof temperatures. A professional roof inspector can pinpoint the cause of the water damage and inform you of whether a replacement is worthwhile.

5. There are Gaps in Your Chimney Flashing

The flashing that surrounds your chimney, skylights, and vents is essential as it can shield these openings from leaks. For this reason, you should always be on the lookout for any breaks or cracks in the flashing. If you do come across these issues, there’s a good chance your roof could benefit from a replacement.

6. Your Roof Is Sagging

A sagging roof is more than an eyesore. It’s a sign that its structure is no longer sound, and you need to replace it. In most cases, a sagging roof is due to wind pressure, improper roof design, or issues with the foundation, walls, or other supporting structures. Regardless of the cause, replacing your sagging roof is likely your best option.

7. Your Roof Has Visible Storm Damage

If your roof has visible storm damage, such as from high winds, heavy rain, hail, fallen tree limbs, or even regular wear and tear, assessing its condition promptly is essential. Storm-related damage can compromise the roof’s structural integrity, leaving your home vulnerable to leaks, energy loss, and further deterioration. In some cases, the damage may require a full replacement.

8. Your Life Circumstances Warrant a Replacement

There are some situations that may cause you to replace your roof. If you’re remodeling your home with an addition, a new roof might be necessary to ensure a uniform look. In the event the roof has undergone extensive storm damage, a repair might not be enough, so you may need to replace it.

Also, if you’re selling your home and it’s old or shows significant signs of wear, a new roof can get more buyers in the door and potentially increase your selling price. In addition, if you’d like to upgrade your roof from traditional asphalt shingles to a metal roof, for example, you’ll need to replace it entirely.